A devastating house fire tore through the home of South Carolina Judge Diane Goodstein this past Saturday, leaving the community shaken. The $1.5 million oceanfront property in Edisto Beach was engulfed in flames, forcing occupants to escape by jumping from an elevated first floor. Emergency responders from St. Paul’s Fire District acted swiftly, evacuating the family—some by kayak due to the home’s remote location and difficult access.
Three people, including Judge Goodstein’s husband Arnold Goodstein, a former Democratic state senator, were hospitalized with injuries such as broken legs from the fall. Judge Goodstein herself was reportedly walking on the nearby beach when the fire broke out.
Authorities say the blaze was caused by an “apparent explosion,” but it remains unclear if the incident was accidental or intentional. The South Carolina State Law Enforcement Division (SLED) is actively investigating.
The timing of the fire has raised eyebrows, coming weeks after Goodstein blocked the Trump Department of Justice’s attempt to obtain personal data of over 3.3 million South Carolina voters, citing privacy concerns. The judge has reportedly faced multiple death threats over the years related to her rulings.
The incident has ignited a political firestorm. Democratic Congressman Daniel Goldman called out White House deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller, accusing him and Trump supporters of fomenting threats against judges like Goodstein. Miller fired back, accusing Democrats of left-wing terrorism and defending his allies.
Goldman challenged Miller to condemn all political violence, emphasizing the urgent need to address threats against judges regardless of politics.
As the investigation continues, the fire underscores the growing tensions and dangers faced by public officials amid polarized political battles.