My grandparents planted the apple tree the week they moved in—a skinny sapling from Grandpa’s family orchard. It grew up with us: through birthdays, graduations, summers when I fell asleep beneath its shade with sticky fingers and grass-stained knees. I’m 35 now, restoring the house they left me, room by room. At the center of it all stands that tree—our living heirloom.
Then Brad and Karen moved in next door.
Brad arrived loud and impatient. Karen wore tight smiles and sharper words. Three weeks later, she stood at my door.
“Your tree’s a problem,” she said. “We’re putting in a hot tub. The shade kills the vibe.”
“It’s entirely on my side,” I said. “It doesn’t cross the fence.”
“Sunlight doesn’t respect property lines,” she replied, as if that settled everything.
The next day, Brad banged on my door. “It’s just a tree.”
“It’s my grandparents’ tree,” I said. “Fifty years old.”
“They’re not around to miss it,” he shrugged.
I offered peace like Grandma would: “When the apples ripen, I’ll bring you some.”
Karen wrinkled her nose. “No thanks.”
I thought it was over—until a neighbor texted me: “Brad and Karen have tree guys. Chainsaws. Wood chipper.”
I checked my security app. Men were in my yard, near the tree.
I drove eight hours without music. When I arrived, the tree was gone—just a raw stump circled by sawdust. I stood there like at a graveside.
Karen answered the door with wine and a smile. “We had it taken down. You’re welcome. More sunlight.”
“It was on my property,” I said.
“Dramatic,” she said, sipping.
Brad smirked. “Send us a thank-you card!”
I called an arborist. He valued the tree at over eighteen thousand dollars.
I sent a legal letter demanding compensation. Two days later, they arrived waving threats.
“You can’t do this! There’ll be no sun!”
“It’s legal,” I said. “Unlike cutting down a neighbor’s tree.”
They left, panicked and defeated.
Now, three evergreens stand where that tree once did—thriving, shading the hot tub, and reminding me that roots matter.
Sometimes I sit beneath them, imagining my grandparents beside me, and I whisper, “You can cut a tree in an afternoon, but it takes a lifetime to earn its shade.”
